Homemade Sugar-Free Apple Butter: A Wholesome Fall Treat

Embrace the flavors of autumn with this incredibly simple and delicious Sugar-Free Apple Butter recipe. Perfect for those seeking a healthier alternative to store-bought spreads, this homemade delight requires just a handful of wholesome ingredients and your trusty slow cooker. Say goodbye to added sugars and artificial flavors, and hello to a naturally sweet, warmly spiced apple butter that’s ready to elevate your favorite fall dishes. Whether you’re meal prepping for the week or looking for a guilt-free treat, this recipe is designed for ease, flavor, and health-conscious living.

This post contains affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure here.

Making your own apple butter is not only incredibly satisfying but also allows you complete control over the ingredients. You can customize the sweetness to your exact preference, or even opt for a completely unsweetened version, letting the natural flavors of the apples shine through. This slow cooker method makes the process virtually hands-off, transforming simple apples and spices into a rich, deeply flavored spread with minimal effort. It’s an ideal way to capture the essence of fall and enjoy a wholesome, sugar-free treat.

What is Apple Butter?

Many people, especially as children, might assume apple butter contains actual butter. But as I quickly learned on our annual fall trips to the pumpkin patch, where apple picking and loading up on apple butter from the general store were traditions, it’s quite different! Apple butter is a fruit preserve made from apples, similar in consistency to a very thick applesauce or jam, but with a richer, more concentrated flavor.

The magic of apple butter comes from slow cooking apples for an extended period. This long cooking process caramelizes the natural sugars in the fruit, deepens its color to a rich brown, and evaporates much of the water content. The result is an incredibly smooth, spreadable fruit spread, usually spiced with warm flavors like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. It’s not just a spread; it’s a testament to how simple ingredients, time, and heat can create something truly extraordinary and comforting. Its thick texture makes it perfect for spreading on various baked goods, providing a burst of concentrated apple flavor without being overly sweet.

Why Make Sugar-Free Apple Butter?

Choosing to make sugar-free apple butter is a fantastic decision for several reasons. Firstly, it allows you to enjoy a classic fall treat without the added sugars often found in commercially prepared versions. Many store-bought spreads contain high fructose corn syrup or large amounts of refined sugar, which can contribute to unwanted calorie intake and blood sugar spikes. By making it at home with natural sugar substitutes, you maintain the delicious flavor while aligning it with a healthier lifestyle, whether you’re managing diabetes, following a keto diet, or simply trying to reduce your sugar consumption.

Secondly, focusing on a sugar-free recipe truly highlights the natural sweetness and tartness of the apples themselves. When you’re not masking the fruit’s inherent flavors with excessive sugar, you get a more authentic and nuanced taste profile. This recipe is designed to be naturally sweet, and you can adjust the amount of sweetener to your exact liking, ensuring a perfect balance every time. It’s a wholesome option that doesn’t compromise on the comforting, spiced apple flavor you love.

What Type of Apples to Use

The beauty of homemade apple butter lies in its versatility, especially when it comes to apple selection. While you can certainly use any apples you have on hand or that are your personal favorites, combining different varieties often yields the most complex and flavorful apple butter. Each apple type brings its own unique characteristics to the mix – some offer sweetness, others tartness, and some contribute a pleasant firmness that breaks down beautifully when cooked.

For this recipe, I find a blend of Fuji and Honeycrisp apples works wonderfully. Honeycrisp apples are known for their crisp texture and balanced sweet-tart flavor, while Fuji apples contribute a lovely sweetness and juiciness. Other popular choices that are excellent for apple butter include Red Delicious, which is very sweet, and Gala, offering a mild, sweet flavor. Granny Smith apples, with their distinct tartness, can also be included to cut through the sweetness, especially if you prefer a less sweet spread or are using very sweet apple varieties. Experimenting with a 2:1 or 3:1 ratio of sweet to tart apples can create a depth of flavor that a single variety might miss. Don’t be afraid to mix and match to find your perfect blend!

Do You Have to Peel the Apples?

One of the most common questions when making apple butter is whether to peel the apples. The good news is, no, you don’t absolutely have to peel them! Leaving the skin on your apples offers several benefits. Apple skins are packed with beneficial nutrients, including fiber and various vitamins and antioxidants, so keeping them on boosts the nutritional profile of your apple butter. The fiber can also contribute to a slightly thicker consistency.

However, for an ultra-smooth and creamy apple butter, peeling the apples can make the blending process easier and result in a more refined texture. If you prefer a rustic texture or don’t mind a few tiny flecks of skin, feel free to leave them on. If you opt to keep the skins, ensure your immersion blender or food processor is powerful enough to fully pulverize them for the smoothest possible finish. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference for texture and the nutritional benefits you seek.

How to Sweeten Your Sugar-Free Apple Butter

Since apples are naturally sweet, you might discover that you prefer your apple butter with little to no added sweetener at all. The long cooking process naturally concentrates the apples’ inherent sugars, bringing out a delicious, subtle sweetness. However, if you desire a sweeter spread without traditional sugar, there are excellent sugar-free alternatives available.

For this recipe, I personally use a combination of Lakanto brown monk fruit sweetener and their classic white monk fruit sweetener. These are fantastic 1:1 replacements for brown and white sugar, offering zero net carbs and zero calories. This makes them a perfect choice for keto-friendly or diabetic diets. You can use the same amount as you would regular sugar in most recipes, making substitution incredibly easy.

Other popular sugar-free sweeteners like erythritol or stevia can also be used, though their sweetness profiles and conversion ratios might vary, so it’s best to check product-specific guidelines. If you prefer a more natural, unrefined sweetener (though not sugar-free), pure maple syrup is another option. While I haven’t tested it extensively in this specific recipe, you could start with about ¼ cup after the initial cooking and adjust to your taste. Always remember to add sweeteners gradually and taste as you go. The amount of sweetener listed in the recipe yields a mildly sweet apple butter. If you enjoy a very sweet spread, don’t hesitate to add more until it perfectly suits your palate after the slow cooking process.

How to Make Apple Butter in a Slow Cooker

Making apple butter in your slow cooker is wonderfully simple and yields incredibly flavorful results with minimal fuss. The slow cooking process allows the flavors to meld beautifully and the apples to break down into a luscious consistency. Here’s a breakdown of the easy steps:

1. Prepare Your Ingredients: Begin by washing, coring, and slicing your chosen apples. Remember, peeling is optional! Add the sliced apples to your slow cooker.
2. Add Flavorings: Next, incorporate your aromatic spices and chosen sweeteners. This includes vanilla extract, ground cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. These spices are essential for that classic, warm apple butter flavor. Stir everything together gently to ensure the apples are evenly coated.
3. Slow Cook to Perfection: Cover your slow cooker and let it work its magic. Cook on high for 4-5 hours or on low for 9-10 hours. The longer cooking time helps caramelize the apples and reduce their moisture content, leading to that rich, deep brown color and concentrated flavor.
4. Puree for Smoothness: Once cooked, remove the lid. The apples should be very tender. Carefully puree the mixture until it reaches your desired smooth consistency. An immersion blender is perfect for this, allowing you to blend directly in the slow cooker. If using a regular blender, transfer the hot apple mixture in batches and blend carefully.
5. Taste and Adjust: This is a crucial step! Taste your freshly made apple butter. If you desire more sweetness, gradually add more of your preferred sugar-free sweetener, blending after each addition until it’s perfect for you. You can also adjust the spices if you wish. The apple butter will continue to thicken as it cools.

And just like that, you’ll have a batch of fragrant, delicious sugar-free apple butter ready to enjoy!

Achieving the Perfect Thick and Creamy Texture

The hallmark of excellent apple butter is its rich, thick, and velvety smooth texture. Achieving this consistency is easier than you might think, especially with the right tools and techniques. The primary method for achieving creaminess involves pureeing the cooked apples.

My preferred tool for this task is an immersion blender. This handheld device allows you to blend the apple mixture directly in your slow cooker pot, minimizing cleanup and making the process incredibly efficient. Simply plunge the immersion blender into the cooked apples and blend until all chunks are gone and you have a smooth, uniform consistency. Continue blending until it reaches your desired level of creaminess.

Alternatively, you can use a regular stand blender. If you opt for this method, proceed with caution: hot apple butter can create steam and pressure in a sealed blender. Always work in small batches, fill the blender only halfway, and remove the center cap of the lid (covering the opening with a kitchen towel) to allow steam to escape. Start blending on a low speed and gradually increase. Blending until completely smooth ensures that signature creamy texture, regardless of whether you peeled your apples or not.

How to Store Homemade Apple Butter

Proper storage is key to extending the life of your delicious homemade sugar-free apple butter. Since this recipe doesn’t involve traditional canning methods that create a shelf-stable seal, it must be stored in the refrigerator or freezer.

Once your apple butter has cooled completely, transfer it into clean, airtight containers. Glass jars with secure lids, such as these glass jars with lids from Amazon, are ideal. They are non-reactive, easy to clean, and allow you to see the contents. Ensure the jars are completely dry before filling. Fill them, leaving a little headspace, and seal them tightly. Always label your containers with the date of preparation so you can easily track its freshness.

Storing your apple butter correctly will help maintain its flavor and prevent spoilage, ensuring you can enjoy this fall treat for weeks to come.

How Long Will it Last?

Your homemade sugar-free apple butter, when stored correctly in an airtight container in the refrigerator, will keep for a considerable amount of time. You can safely enjoy it for up to one month. The natural acidity of the apples and the absence of fresh dairy help it stay fresh, but proper sealing is paramount to prevent any unwanted moisture or air exposure that could lead to spoilage. Always use clean utensils when scooping out the apple butter to avoid introducing contaminants.

Freezing Apple Butter for Longer Storage

If you’ve made a large batch or simply want to enjoy the taste of fall well into the colder months, freezing your sugar-free apple butter is an excellent option. When properly frozen, it can last for an impressive 9 months to a year without losing its quality or flavor. This makes it perfect for batch cooking and enjoying year-round.

To freeze, first ensure the apple butter is completely cooled. Then, transfer it into freezer-safe containers or heavy-duty freezer bags. For convenience, I often use freezer molds, which allow you to freeze apple butter in portioned servings. Once frozen solid in the molds, you can pop out the portions and store them in a larger freezer bag or container, saving space. Remember to label everything with the date.

When you’re ready to enjoy it, simply transfer the frozen apple butter to your refrigerator and allow it to defrost overnight. It will be ready to use by morning, maintaining its delicious taste and smooth texture.

What to Pair With This Delicious Apple Butter

The rich, spiced flavor of sugar-free apple butter makes it an incredibly versatile spread that can enhance a variety of dishes, both sweet and savory. Its natural sweetness and warm spices complement many different foods, making it a perfect addition to your breakfast, brunch, or even as an ingredient in other recipes. Here are some fantastic pairing ideas:

• Breakfast Staples: Spread generously on warm toast, fluffy pancakes, crispy waffles, or fresh biscuits. Stir a spoonful into your morning oatmeal or yogurt for a flavorful boost.
• Baked Goods: Serve alongside freshly baked Cornbread Muffins or Pumpkin Muffins. It’s also delightful on scones or quick breads.
• Cheese Boards: A unique addition to a Charcuterie Board, pairing wonderfully with sharp cheeses like cheddar or smoked gouda.
• As an Ingredient: Use it as a glaze for pork or chicken, a filling for pastries, or even as a sweetener in smoothies.
• Desserts: Dollop it on top of ice cream or use it as a healthier alternative in apple crisp or pie fillings.

Don’t limit yourself to these suggestions – experiment and discover new ways to enjoy this wholesome and flavorful spread!

More Healthy Sugar-Free Recipes

If you’re looking to expand your repertoire of delicious, sugar-free treats, you’re in luck! Here are some more fantastic recipes that allow you to indulge without the added sugar:

• Sugar-Free Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
• Sugar-Free Cheesecake
• Healthy Southern Sweet Potato Pie
• Healthy Southern Peach Cobbler
• Sugar-Free Blueberry Crisp
• Sugar-Free Banana Bread
• Sugar Free Pound Cake
• Sugar Free Cookie Dough
• Sugar Free Hot Chocolate
• Slow Cooker Crockpot Cranberry Sauce

More Delectable Apple Recipes

Apples are incredibly versatile and perfect for both sweet and savory dishes. If you’re a fan of apples, you’ll love these other delicious recipes:

• Sugar-Free Apple Pies
• Slow Cooker Crockpot Apple Oatmeal
• Sugar-Free Apple Crisp
• Instant-Pot Apple Steel Cut Oats
• Cranberry Sauce with Apples
• Caramel Apple Spice Starbucks
• Slow Cooker Crockpot Baked Apples
• Southern Fried Apples

Sugar-Free Apple Butter

Author: Brandi Crawford

This Sugar-Free Apple Butter recipe is perfect for fall and only requires a handful of ingredients. This healthy spread has no-added sugar and can be made in your slow cooker or Crockpot.

Rated 5 stars from 5 votes.

Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

Recipe Details

Prep Time: 10 mins

Cook Time: 10 hrs

Total Time: 10 hrs 10 mins

Course: Appetizer, Preserves, Spread

Cuisine: American

Servings: 4 cups

Calories: 71 kcal

Want to save this recipe for later?

I’ll email it to you, so you can come back to it later! You will also get our free digital cookbook with 30-Minute One-Pot Recipes and weekly recipes and tips.

(Email capture form removed as per instructions.)

Equipment

• Slow Cooker
• Apple Slicer and Corer
• Freezer Soup Molds
• Mason Jars
• Immersion Blender
• Apple Peeler

Ingredients

• 3 pounds Honeycrisp apples (Cored. See notes.)
• 2 pounds Fuji apples (Cored.)
• ½ cup sweetener (See notes.)
• ½ cup brown sweetener
• ½ tablespoon vanilla extract
• ½ tablespoon ground cinnamon
• ¼ teaspoon ground nutmeg
• ¼ teaspoon ground cloves

Instructions

1. Add the apples, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, ground cloves, and sweeteners to the slow cooker.
2. Cook on High for 4-5 hours or on Low for 9-10 hours.
3. Remove the lid and carefully puree the mixture with an immersion blender until smooth, or transfer to a regular blender in batches. Be cautious when blending hot liquids.
4. Taste repeatedly and adjust sweetener and spices to your preference. The apple butter will thicken further as it cools.

Notes

• You can use any variety of apples. If you have favorites, go for those. Red Delicious and Gala are also excellent choices for apple butter, offering a good balance of sweetness.
• Peeling the apples is optional. The skins contain many nutrients and fiber. Leaving them on will create a slightly more rustic texture, but you can achieve a very creamy butter by blending thoroughly.
• Always add sweeteners to taste. The amount specified in the recipe yields a mildly sweet apple butter. If you prefer a very sweet spread, I recommend starting with ¼ cup of additional sweetener after the apple butter has cooked. Taste, and add more as needed until it reaches your desired sweetness.
• Feel free to use all brown sweetener or all white sweetener if you prefer. I personally enjoy the depth of flavor from combining both.
• If you are not making this sugar-free, you can use refined table sugar in the same amounts indicated for the sweeteners.
• Pure maple syrup can also be used as a natural sweetener (not sugar-free). I have not tested this within the recipe, but you could start with ¼ cup and adjust to your taste after cooking.
• This recipe is specifically developed for a slow cooker and has not been tested with an Instant Pot or pressure cooker. Pressure cooking often requires added liquid, which is not ideal for apple butter as we aim for a thick, concentrated consistency.
• To adjust the portion, you can halve the ingredients. Keep a close watch on the cooking time, as it might need slight adjustment, though typically the longer cooking times remain similar.

Nutrition

Serving: 0.25 cupCalories: 71 kcalCarbohydrates: 16 g

Nutrition Data Disclaimer

Macros are provided as a courtesy and should not be construed as a guarantee. This information is calculated using MyFitnessPal.com. To obtain the most accurate nutritional information in a given recipe, you should calculate the nutritional information with the actual ingredients used in your recipe, using your preferred nutrition calculator. You are solely responsible for ensuring that any nutritional information provided is accurate, complete, and useful.

Mention @Stay_Snatched or tag #StaySnatched if you tried this recipe!

Check out our videos on Youtube!

Let us know how it was!