The Ultimate Crabwich

Embark on a culinary journey with these exquisite homemade crab cake sandwiches, a dish that epitomizes gourmet comfort food. Each bite bursts with the unparalleled flavor of fresh, succulent lump crab meat, expertly seasoned with vibrant lemon juice and the iconic blend of Old Bay Seasoning. Crowned with a luxurious remoulade sauce and nestled within a perfectly toasted brioche bun, these sandwiches are designed to delight every palate. Forget the bland, breadcrumb-heavy versions; our recipe focuses on maximizing the rich, sweet essence of crab, ensuring a truly unforgettable dining experience.

This post contains affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure here.

Table of Contents

Key Ingredients for Unforgettable Crab Cakes

Creating exceptional crab cake sandwiches begins with a careful selection of fresh, high-quality ingredients. Each component plays a crucial role in developing the rich flavor and perfect texture that define this classic dish.

• Mayonnaise: Acts as the binding agent and provides moisture, ensuring the crab cakes remain tender and succulent.
• Lump Crab Meat: The star of the show, offering substantial, flavorful chunks of crab. Quality here makes all the difference.
• Breadcrumbs: A minimal amount helps bind the cakes without overpowering the delicate crab flavor.
• Worcestershire Sauce: Adds a subtle umami depth and a hint of tanginess, enhancing the overall savory profile.
• Mustard (Dijon or Standard): Contributes a sharp, piquant note that complements the richness of the crab.
• Fresh Lemon Juice: Brightens the flavors, cutting through the richness and adding a refreshing citrusy zest.
• Egg: Another key binder that helps hold the crab cakes together during cooking.
• Old Bay Seasoning: The quintessential crab seasoning, delivering a complex blend of savory, spicy, and aromatic notes that are synonymous with authentic Maryland crab cakes.
• Buns: The vessel for your delicious crab cakes. Brioche is highly recommended for its buttery richness, but other varieties work well too.

Choosing the Best Crab Meat: Lump vs. Other Varieties

The quality of your crab meat is paramount to the success of your crab cake sandwiches. For a truly superior result, selecting fresh, high-quality crab meat, free of shells or cartilage, is essential. While various types of crab meat are available, lump crab meat stands out as the premium choice for crab cakes.

Lump crab meat is distinguished by its large, intact flakes and boasts a sweet, delicate flavor. These substantial chunks originate from the body of the crab, offering a meaty texture that holds up beautifully in a crab cake. Unlike claw or backfin meat, which are smaller and more shredded, lump crab meat provides that satisfying, succulent bite that connoisseurs seek.

While often more expensive due to the careful process required to extract it from the crab, the investment in lump crab meat is well worth it for the superior taste and texture it imparts to your sandwiches. Always prioritize fresh or pasteurized lump crab meat over frozen or canned varieties when possible, as this will yield the best flavor and consistency. When inspecting the crab meat, look for a clean, sweet aroma and a pearly white color, indicating freshness.

Mastering the Art of Seasoning: Spices and Flavors

The magic of a great crab cake lies not just in the quality of the crab, but also in the delicate balance of its seasoning. We aim to enhance, not mask, the natural sweetness of the crab. Here’s how each element contributes to a symphony of flavors:

• Old Bay Seasoning: This iconic blend is non-negotiable for authentic crab cakes, particularly those inspired by Maryland’s rich culinary heritage. Its unique mix of celery salt, black pepper, paprika, and other secret spices provides a savory, slightly spicy, and distinctly aromatic foundation that perfectly complements seafood.
• Mustard (Standard or Dijon): A touch of mustard adds a pleasant tanginess that brightens the crab meat. Dijon mustard offers a more robust, slightly spicier kick, while standard yellow mustard provides a milder, more classic flavor. Both also act as an emulsifier, helping to bind the ingredients together.
• Worcestershire Sauce: This fermented condiment, with its complex blend of vinegar, molasses, tamarind, and various spices, introduces a deep, savory, and subtly sweet umami note. It adds a layer of sophistication to the crab cake mixture.
• Fresh Lemon Juice: A squeeze of fresh lemon juice is crucial. Its bright, acidic profile cuts through the richness of the crab and other ingredients, adding a fresh, zesty finish that makes the flavors pop. Always use fresh lemon juice for the best results; bottled juice simply doesn’t compare.
• Salt and Pepper: These fundamental seasonings are added to taste, allowing you to fine-tune the overall flavor profile. Remember, Old Bay Seasoning already contains salt, so season cautiously and adjust as needed.

Crafting the Perfect Crab Cake Sandwich: Step-by-Step

Creating these delicious crab cake sandwiches is a straightforward process, focusing on gentle handling to preserve the delicate crab meat and proper cooking to achieve a golden, crispy exterior with a tender interior. For precise measurements and a detailed recipe card, please refer to the bottom of this post.

1. Prepare the Flavor Base: In a large mixing bowl, combine the Worcestershire sauce, your choice of mustard (Dijon or standard), fresh lemon juice, egg, mayonnaise, Old Bay Seasoning, and a pinch of salt and pepper. Whisk these ingredients thoroughly until well combined and smooth. This creates the flavorful binder for your crab cakes.
2. Gently Combine Crab and Breadcrumbs: Carefully add the lump crab meat and breadcrumbs to the wet mixture. The key here is to fold them in very gently, using a spatula or your hands, to avoid breaking up the large, beautiful chunks of crab meat. The goal is to bind the mixture just enough without pulverizing the crab. Remember, we want crab-forward cakes!
3. Form the Patties: Divide the mixture into four equal portions. Gently shape each portion into a firm, round patty, about 1-inch thick. If the mixture feels too loose to form patties, you can add another tablespoon or two of breadcrumbs until it holds its shape. Place the formed patties on a plate and refrigerate them for at least 15-20 minutes. This chilling step is essential as it helps the patties firm up, preventing them from falling apart during cooking.
4. Choose Your Cooking Method: Once the patties are chilled, they are ready for cooking. You have several versatile options to achieve that perfect golden crust and tender center: pan-searing, air frying, or baking. Each method offers a slightly different texture and preparation experience, allowing you to choose what best fits your preference and available equipment.
5. Assemble Your Masterpiece: After cooking, let the crab cakes cool slightly. While they are still warm, it’s time to assemble your sandwiches. Toast your chosen buns, add your favorite toppings, and drizzle generously with a creamy remoulade sauce. This final step brings all the elements together for an irresistible bite.

Ensuring Perfection: How to Tell When Your Crab Cakes Are Cooked

Properly cooked crab cakes are a delight – crispy on the outside, tender and flavorful on the inside. Knowing how to determine their doneness is crucial for both taste and food safety. Here are key indicators:

• Visual Cues: Look for a beautiful golden-brown crust on the exterior of the crab cakes, regardless of the cooking method. This caramelized surface signifies a delightful crispness and indicates that the heat has penetrated sufficiently. A deeper golden hue often means more flavor.
• Internal Temperature: For optimal food safety and doneness, use a meat thermometer. Insert it into the thickest part of a crab cake. The internal temperature should register between 140-160 degrees Fahrenheit (60-71 degrees Celsius). This range ensures the crab meat is thoroughly cooked without becoming dry.
• Firmness: Gently press on the center of a crab cake with a spatula. A cooked crab cake will feel firm and hold its shape well. If it feels soft, mushy, or tends to fall apart, it likely needs more cooking time. Conversely, if it feels overly hard, it might be overcooked.
• Aroma: As crab cakes cook, they release a wonderfully aromatic scent of seafood and spices. While not a definitive indicator of doneness, it’s a pleasant sign that things are progressing nicely.

The Foundation: Selecting the Ideal Bread for Your Sandwich

The bread you choose for your crab cake sandwich is more than just a holder; it’s an integral part of the experience, offering texture, flavor, and structure. While personal preference certainly plays a role, certain breads truly elevate the crab cake experience.

I wholeheartedly recommend Brioche buns. Their subtly sweet, buttery, and incredibly soft texture provides a luxurious contrast to the savory, slightly crisp crab cake. When lightly toasted, brioche develops a delicate crunch on the outside while remaining pillowy soft on the inside, creating the perfect embrace for your crab cake. The richness of brioche also complements the sweetness of the crab beautifully.

However, the beauty of a homemade sandwich is its adaptability. Feel free to experiment with other popular choices:

• Ciabatta Rolls: For those who prefer a chewier texture and a more rustic feel, ciabatta rolls are an excellent option. Their open, airy crumb is great for soaking up sauces, and their crusty exterior adds a satisfying bite.
• Whole Wheat Buns: A healthier alternative, whole wheat buns offer a nutty flavor and more fiber. Look for a softer variety to avoid overpowering the delicate crab.
• Pretzel Buns: If you’re seeking something unique, pretzel buns provide a distinctive chewy texture and a savory, slightly salty flavor that pairs surprisingly well with crab.
• Kaiser Rolls: These classic, sturdy rolls offer good structural integrity, making them ideal for holding generous toppings without falling apart. Their slightly crusty exterior and soft interior are a reliable choice.

Ultimately, the best bread is the one you enjoy most. Just remember to lightly toast it, as this enhances its flavor and prevents it from becoming soggy.

The Ultimate Accompaniment: Sauces for Your Crab Cake Sandwich

No crab cake sandwich is complete without a luscious sauce to tie all the flavors together. While the crab cakes themselves are bursting with flavor, a complementary sauce adds an extra layer of complexity and moisture, elevating the entire dish. My top recommendation is a classic Remoulade sauce.

Remoulade is a mayonnaise-based sauce, often enhanced with finely chopped pickles, capers, herbs (like parsley or chives), a touch of mustard (Dijon or Creole), and a hint of heat from ingredients like hot sauce or cayenne pepper. Its creamy texture and tangy, slightly spicy profile perfectly cut through the richness of the crab, providing a harmonious balance of flavors. The bright, briny notes of the pickles and capers offer a refreshing counterpoint to the savory crab.

However, if remoulade isn’t your preference or you’re looking for other delicious options, consider these equally delightful choices:

• Tartar Sauce: A perennial favorite with seafood, tartar sauce is a simple yet effective blend of mayonnaise, chopped pickles or relish, onions, and sometimes capers. Its creamy, tangy profile is a comforting and familiar pairing.
• Mayonnaise: For purists, a good quality mayonnaise might be all you need. Its rich creaminess allows the pure flavor of the crab cake to shine through while adding a smooth texture. You can elevate it with a squeeze of lemon or a dash of hot sauce.
• Aioli Sauce: A sophisticated cousin to mayonnaise, aioli is typically garlic-infused and often includes olive oil. Its rich, garlicky flavor adds a gourmet touch and pairs wonderfully with the sweetness of the crab.
• Cocktail Sauce: While more commonly associated with chilled shrimp, a tangy, zesty cocktail sauce can provide a lively kick for those who enjoy a spicier, more horseradish-forward flavor with their crab cakes.

Don’t be afraid to experiment and find your perfect match!

Customizing Your Crab Cakes: Substitutions and Flavorful Add-ins

While our recipe provides a classic and delicious foundation, one of the joys of cooking at home is the ability to customize. Feel free to experiment with these substitutions and add-ins to tailor your crab cakes to your specific taste preferences or to simply use what you have on hand.

• Fresh Herbs:
  • Cilantro: Adds a fresh, bright, and slightly citrusy note, particularly good if you enjoy a more South-Western or Asian-inspired flavor profile.
  • Dill: A classic pairing with seafood, dill offers a delicate, feathery, and slightly anise-like flavor that enhances the crab’s natural sweetness.
  • Chives: These mild onion-flavored herbs provide a subtle oniony zest without the harshness of raw onion, adding freshness and a hint of color.
• Spice Variations:
  • Smoked Paprika: Infuses a smoky depth and a beautiful reddish hue, adding warmth and complexity.
  • Cayenne Pepper: For those who love a bit more heat, a pinch of cayenne will add a noticeable fiery kick.
  • Cajun Seasoning: If you enjoy bolder, spicier flavors, a dash of Cajun seasoning (in addition to or instead of Old Bay) can transform your crab cakes with its distinct blend of spices.
• Vegetable Additions (Finely Diced):
  • Diced Onions (Yellow or Red): A small amount of very finely diced onion can add a subtle savory pungency. Sautéing them first can mellow their flavor.
  • Diced Bell Peppers (Red, Green, or Yellow): Adds a touch of sweetness, crunch, and vibrant color. Red bell peppers are particularly sweet.
• Cheese (Finely Shredded):
  • Parmesan Cheese: Contributes a salty, nutty, and umami richness.
  • Cheddar Cheese: For a more indulgent and familiar flavor, cheddar can add a creamy, sharp note. Be mindful not to overpower the crab.

When adding extras, remember to keep the quantities modest to ensure the delicate crab flavor remains the star of your crab cakes.

Elevate Your Sandwich: Essential Toppings

Once your perfectly cooked crab cakes are ready, the final step in creating an unforgettable sandwich is to choose the right toppings. These additions provide a crucial balance of textures, flavors, and freshness that complement the rich crab cake. Here are some classic and popular choices:

• Lettuce: Crisp lettuce, such as romaine or iceberg, adds a refreshing crunch and a cool contrast to the warm crab cake. It also provides a vital layer of freshness.
• Tomatoes: Slices of ripe, juicy tomatoes offer a burst of acidity and a soft texture that beautifully complements the savory crab. Heirloom tomatoes can add an extra layer of flavor and visual appeal.
• Onions: Thinly sliced red onion or sweet onion can provide a sharp, pungent bite that cuts through richness. For a milder flavor, try quick-pickled red onions.
• Avocado: Creamy, rich avocado slices add a luxurious texture and a mild, buttery flavor that pairs wonderfully with seafood. It’s a fantastic way to add healthy fats and a gourmet touch.
• Pickles: Dill pickle slices or sweet pickle relish offer a tangy, briny crunch that provides a delightful counterpoint to the richness of the crab cake and sauce.
• Bacon: For an indulgent twist, crispy bacon strips introduce a smoky, salty flavor and an irresistible crunch. The “surf and turf” combination is always a crowd-pleaser.

Feel free to mix and match these toppings to create your ideal crab cake sandwich masterpiece!

Perfect Pairings: What to Serve with Crab Cake Sandwiches

To complete your meal, consider pairing your delicious crab cake sandwiches with some complementary side dishes. These options are designed to either enhance the flavors of your main dish or provide a refreshing contrast, creating a well-rounded and satisfying feast.

• Crispy Air Fryer French Fries: A classic and universally loved pairing. Crispy fries offer a satisfying crunch and salty counterpoint.
• Golden Air Fryer Onion Rings: For another delightful fried side, onion rings add a sweet and savory element with a wonderfully crisp texture.
• Healthy Air Fryer Green Beans: If you’re looking for a lighter, vegetable-focused side, green beans cooked in the air fryer are simple, fresh, and delicious.
• Hearty Traeger Smoked Baked Beans: For a more substantial and smoky side, these baked beans offer a sweet and savory depth that pairs well with the richness of crab.
• Luxurious Steakhouse Creamed Spinach: An elegant and creamy vegetable side that adds a touch of sophistication to your meal.
• Simple Coleslaw: A crisp, tangy coleslaw is always a fantastic choice with seafood, offering a refreshing crunch and a hint of acidity.
• Fresh Garden Salad: A light and vibrant green salad with a vinaigrette dressing can cut through the richness of the sandwich and cleanse the palate.

More Delicious Sandwich Recipes to Explore

If you’ve enjoyed crafting these crab cake sandwiches, you might be keen to explore other exciting sandwich creations. Here are a few more recipes that promise to deliver flavor and satisfaction:

• Spicy Blackened Chicken Sandwich: A flavorful chicken sandwich with a bold, zesty kick.
• Crispy Air Fryer Chicken Sandwich: Enjoy a perfectly crispy chicken sandwich with less oil, thanks to your air fryer.
• Classic Crispy Fish Sandwich: Another seafood favorite, featuring flaky, crispy fish on a bun.
• Savory Shrimp Burgers: A creative alternative to traditional burgers, packed with succulent shrimp.

Crab Cake Sandwiches

Author: Brandi Crawford

These homemade Crab Cake Sandwiches are bursting with fresh lump crab meat and perfectly seasoned with fresh lemon juice and Old Bay Seasoning. Drizzled in epic remoulade sauce and served with toasted brioche buns, everyone will love these!

Want to save this recipe for later? Pin it on Pinterest or share with a friend!

Summary

Prep Time: 15 mins

Cook Time: 10 mins

Total Time: 25 mins

Course: Dinner, Lunch

Cuisine: American, Maryland

Servings: 4 servings

Calories: 344 kcal

Equipment You’ll Need

• Cast Iron Skillet
• Cosori 7-quart Air Fryer
• Large Mixing Bowl
• Whisk
• Spatula
• Baking Sheet (for oven method)
• Parchment Paper (for oven method)

Ingredients List

• ¼ cup mayo
• 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
• 1 teaspoon mustard (standard or Dijon)
• ½ tablespoon fresh lemon juice
• 1 large egg
• ½ tablespoon Old Bay Seasoning
• Salt and pepper to taste
• 8 oz lump crab meat, picked over for shells
• 2-3 tablespoons breadcrumbs (adjust as needed)
• Cooking oil (I used olive oil)
• 4 brioche buns (or your preferred buns)

Detailed Instructions

1. In a large bowl, whisk together the Worcestershire sauce, mustard, lemon juice, egg, mayo, Old Bay Seasoning, salt, and pepper until well combined.
2. Gently fold in the lump crab meat and breadcrumbs, being careful not to break up the large chunks of crab.
3. Divide the mixture into four equal portions and gently shape each portion into a patty. If the patties are too soft, add a little more breadcrumbs. For best results, chill the patties in the refrigerator for 15-20 minutes before cooking.

Stovetop/Pan Seared Instructions

1. Heat a cast iron skillet or heavy-bottomed pan over medium-high heat and add a drizzle of cooking oil.
2. Once the oil is hot and shimmering, carefully place the crab cake patties in the skillet. Cook for 3-4 minutes per side, or until they are golden brown and cooked through (internal temperature 140-160°F).
3. Remove from skillet and allow the crab cakes to cool slightly before handling and assembling.

Air Fryer Instructions

1. Lightly spray the air fryer basket with cooking oil to prevent sticking.
2. Place the crab cakes in a single layer in the air fryer basket. Spray the top of the crab cakes with cooking oil.
3. Cook at 370°F (188°C) for 8-12 minutes, flipping halfway through, or until golden brown and cooked through (internal temperature 140-160°F). Cook time may vary based on patty size and air fryer model.
4. Allow the crab cakes to fully cook before moving them from the basket, as they can be fragile when hot.

Oven/Baked Instructions

1. Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C).
2. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or lightly grease it with cooking spray or olive oil.
3. Place the crab cake patties on the prepared baking sheet, ensuring there is some space between each patty for even cooking.
4. Bake for 15-20 minutes, or until they are golden brown and cooked through (internal temperature 140-160°F).
5. As with other methods, allow the crab cakes to cool slightly before moving to prevent them from breaking apart.

Assembling the Sandwiches

1. While the crab cakes are cooking, lightly toast your buns to your desired crispness.
2. To assemble, spread your desired sauce (like remoulade) on the toasted bun halves. Layer with fresh lettuce, tomato slices, a cooked crab cake, and any other preferred toppings.
3. Serve immediately and enjoy your gourmet homemade crab cake sandwich!

Chef’s Notes and Tips

• This recipe is crafted to highlight the crab flavor with minimal breading. If you prefer a thicker, more breaded crab cake, you can increase the breadcrumbs to ½ cup.
• Feel free to use either standard yellow mustard or Dijon mustard based on your preference for tanginess and spice.
• Properly cooked crab cakes will develop a beautiful golden-brown, crispy crust on the outside.
• Always use a meat thermometer to confirm the internal temperature reaches 140-160°F (60-71°C) for safe consumption and optimal texture.
• To prevent crab cakes from falling apart, handle them gently and ensure they are adequately chilled before cooking.
• Leftover crab cakes can be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2-3 days. Reheat gently in an air fryer or oven to retain crispness.

Nutrition Information

Serving: 1 sandwich

Calories: 344 kcal

Carbohydrates: 32g

Protein: 20g

Fat: 15g

Disclaimer on Nutrition Data

Macros are provided as a courtesy and should not be construed as a guarantee. This information is calculated using tools like MyFitnessPal.com. To obtain the most accurate nutritional information for any given recipe, you should calculate it with the actual ingredients used in your recipe, using your preferred nutrition calculator. You are solely responsible for ensuring that any nutritional information provided is accurate, complete, and useful for your specific dietary needs.

Tried this recipe? Let us know how it was by leaving a comment below!

Connect with us on social media! Mention @Stay_Snatched or tag #StaySnatched on Instagram!

For more culinary inspiration and cooking tutorials, subscribe to our YouTube Channel!