Indulge Guilt-Free: The Ultimate Sugar-Free No-Bake Key Lime Pie (Low Carb & Keto-Friendly)

Craving a refreshing dessert that won’t derail your healthy eating goals? This incredible Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie is your perfect solution! It’s an effortlessly easy no-bake recipe, completely egg-free, and proudly low-carb and keto-friendly. Imagine a perfectly sweet, crisp graham cracker-style crust paired with a lusciously zesty, smooth lime custard filling – all crafted without a single gram of added sugar. This recipe proves that healthy living doesn’t mean sacrificing flavor or the joy of indulging in your favorite treats.

This post contains affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure here.

One of the most appealing aspects of this dessert is its reliance on simple, wholesome ingredients. Too often, healthy dessert recipes can seem intimidating due to obscure components. Not this one! We stick to the basics, ensuring accessibility and ease for every home baker, with the star exception of the unique key limes themselves. We’ll guide you through finding and using these tiny powerhouses of flavor.

The Difference Between Key Limes and Regular Limes: A Citrus Deep Dive

When it comes to citrus, not all limes are created equal. Key limes, often referred to as Mexican limes or West Indian limes, possess a distinct charm that sets them apart from their larger, more common Persian lime cousins. Visually, key limes are considerably smaller, typically about the size of a golf ball, with a slightly yellowish-green hue when fully ripe, rather than the vibrant green of regular limes. Their skin is thinner and smoother, making them a bit trickier to zest and juice, but the effort is undeniably rewarding.

The true magic of key limes lies in their flavor profile. They are celebrated for their bolder, more aromatic essence, often described as having a delicate floral undertone that regular limes simply lack. While both are acidic, key limes boast a sharper, more intensely tart flavor, which is precisely why they’re the star of this classic pie. This unique blend of acidity and floral notes creates a complex, bright taste that is absolutely essential for an authentic key lime pie experience.

Finding key limes can sometimes be a treasure hunt. They are usually available in specialty grocery stores, farmer’s markets, or international food markets, particularly Mexican grocers. If you live in a region where they are not commonly grown, your local supermarket might carry them seasonally. If fresh key limes prove elusive, don’t despair! Regular lime juice can be used as a substitute, though the final pie will have a slightly less nuanced, more generally “lime” flavor rather than the distinctive “key lime” character.

Due to their petite size, you’ll find yourself needing quite a few key limes to extract the necessary juice for this recipe. For instance, a pound of key limes typically yields approximately ½ cup of juice. It’s always a good idea to have a little extra on hand, just in case, especially if you plan to use some for garnish.

How to Store Key Limes for Optimal Freshness

Proper storage is key to extending the life and preserving the vibrant flavor of your key limes. Unlike many fruits that benefit from refrigeration, key limes thrive at a cool room temperature. Storing them in the refrigerator can actually accelerate their decay, causing them to dry out and lose their precious juice and aromatic qualities more quickly. Find a cool, dry spot on your countertop or in your pantry away from direct sunlight.

It’s important to note that key limes generally have a shorter shelf life than standard limes. While regular limes can last for several weeks in the fridge, key limes are best used within a few days to a week of purchase. For this reason, it’s wise to plan your baking shortly after acquiring them. If you buy a larger quantity, consider juicing and zesting some immediately and freezing the juice and zest for future use. This proactive approach ensures you always have that bright key lime flavor at your fingertips, even out of season. For more detailed insights, you can explore resources on how to store key limes effectively.

Navigating Sweeteners: The Best Options for Your Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie

Choosing the right sweetener is paramount for a truly delicious sugar-free and low-carb key lime pie. Our preferred choice is monk fruit sweetener. This natural, plant-based sweetener is an excellent option for several reasons:

• **Zero Calorie & Zero Carb:** It allows you to enjoy the sweetness without impacting your daily caloric or carbohydrate intake, making it ideal for keto and low-carb diets.
• **Blood Sugar Friendly:** Monk fruit does not spike blood sugar levels, making it suitable for individuals managing diabetes or looking to maintain stable energy.
• **1:1 Sugar Replacement:** Most monk fruit sweeteners are formulated to measure cup-for-cup like refined table sugar, simplifying conversions in recipes.

If you’re not concerned about carbohydrates or calories, you can easily substitute the same amount of regular table sugar as specified in the recipe. However, for those maintaining a sugar-free lifestyle, other excellent alternatives include erythritol (often found in blends like Swerve or Truvia) and stevia. When using stevia, always follow the conversion guidelines provided by the manufacturer, as its potency is much higher than sugar or monk fruit.

It’s worth noting that sweeteners can have varying aftertastes for different people. Monk fruit is generally well-regarded for its clean taste, but always use a brand you enjoy. Experimentation might be necessary to find your perfect match. If you prefer a natural, unrefined sugar option and are not strictly sugar-free, you could also use pure, organic maple syrup in the filling. For this substitution, use approximately ½ cup of maple syrup for ¾ cup of granular sweetener, or ⅓ cup for ½ cup of granular sweetener, adjusting to your taste preferences and considering the liquid volume it adds to the filling.

The Role of Gelatin in Achieving the Perfect No-Bake Pie Texture

In no-bake pies, gelatin is an unsung hero. It serves as a crucial thickening agent, giving the custard filling its signature firm yet smooth texture without the need for eggs or baking. Gelatin’s unique properties allow it to solidify when chilled and remain stable at room temperature, making it ideal for desserts that don’t go into the oven. When heated, however, it transforms into a liquid state.

This characteristic is vital to understand for success with this recipe. The instructions call for warming the key lime juice – a critical step that ensures the gelatin fully dissolves. However, it’s equally important not to overheat or boil the juice. If the juice gets too hot, the gelatin’s gelling power can be diminished, potentially resulting in a filling that fails to set properly. You want the juice just warm enough to thoroughly dissolve the gelatin granules, creating a smooth, homogenous mixture that will then thicken as it cools and chills.

For this recipe, we recommend using unflavored gelatin. This ensures you maintain full control over the sweetness and flavor of your pie, as it contains no added sugars or artificial ingredients. While products like Jell-O are readily available, their regular versions are loaded with sugar, and sugar-free varieties often contain artificial sweeteners that we aim to avoid in this clean recipe. If you follow a vegan or vegetarian diet, agar-agar flakes or powder can be a suitable alternative. When substituting agar-agar for gelatin, generally use a 1:1 ratio (by weight) or refer to the specific product’s instructions, as its gelling strength can vary.

Mastering the Art: How to Make Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie

Creating this delightful Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie is a surprisingly straightforward process, proving that healthy desserts can be both delicious and simple. The beauty of this recipe lies in its no-bake nature, eliminating the need for complex baking techniques or precise oven temperatures. It’s truly a beginner-friendly project that yields impressive results.

The entire process is divided into two main components: preparing the flavorful, low-carb crust and then mixing the vibrant, zesty filling. Both steps are designed for ease, minimizing fuss and maximizing enjoyment. Below, we provide a general overview of the steps involved, with detailed serving sizes and comprehensive instructions available in the complete recipe card.

1. **Prepare the Gelatin Mixture:** Gently warm the fresh key lime juice, then carefully whisk in the unflavored gelatin until it’s completely dissolved. This crucial step ensures a perfectly set pie.
2. **Whip the Creamy Base:** In a mixing bowl, combine softened cream cheese, your chosen zero-calorie sweetener, fresh key lime zest, and plain Greek yogurt (or sour cream). Beat these ingredients until the mixture is wonderfully smooth and lump-free.
3. **Combine and Mix:** Gradually incorporate the dissolved lime juice and gelatin mixture into the creamy base. Mix thoroughly, ensuring all ingredients are well combined to achieve a uniform texture and flavor.
4. **Fill the Crust:** Pour the luscious key lime filling into your prepared graham cracker-style crust, spreading it evenly.
5. **Chill to Perfection:** The final, and arguably most important, step is chilling. Allow the pie ample time in the refrigerator for the gelatin to set and the flavors to meld, resulting in a firm, sliceable, and utterly delicious dessert.

Understanding and Customizing Your Key Lime Pie’s Flavor Profile

Traditional key lime pie achieves its iconic balance through the rich sweetness of sweetened condensed milk, which perfectly counters the intense tartness of key limes. However, sweetened condensed milk is typically laden with refined sugar and often high-fructose corn syrup, making it unsuitable for a sugar-free and low-carb recipe. In our healthy rendition, we ingeniously replace it with a combination of cream cheese, plain full-fat Greek yogurt (or sour cream), and a zero-calorie sweetener.

This innovative blend not only creates an incredibly creamy, tangy custard but also gives you direct control over the pie’s taste. Since this recipe omits eggs, which often bind and set traditional custards, you have the freedom to taste and adjust the filling as you go. This is a game-changer for achieving your preferred balance of sweet and tart.

**Here’s how to customize your pie to perfection:**

• **For a Moderately Tart, Sweet Pie (Recommended Starting Point):** Begin with ½ cup of key lime juice, ½ tablespoon of key lime zest, and ¾ cup of your chosen zero-calorie sweetener. Mix these thoroughly, then taste. This combination typically yields a wonderfully balanced pie with a noticeable lime kick and satisfying sweetness. If you desire a stronger lime presence, you can add an additional ½ tablespoon of zest, bringing the total to 1 tablespoon.
• **For a Boldly Tart, Less Sweet Pie:** If you’re a true key lime purist who loves a pronounced tartness, use ½ cup of key lime juice, 1 tablespoon of key lime zest, and only ½ cup of sweetener. This will result in a vibrant, zesty pie with a significantly bolder lime flavor and less overall sweetness.

The key to success is to **taste, taste, taste** the filling repeatedly before pouring it into the crust. Remember, once an ingredient is added, it cannot be easily removed. Start conservatively with zest and sweetener, then gradually add more until the filling perfectly suits your palate. Use the guidelines above as a starting point, but let your taste buds be your ultimate guide for your ideal homemade low carb key lime pie.

Crafting Your Homemade Low-Carb “Graham Cracker” Crust

While many sugar-free key lime pie recipes might suggest a store-bought crust for convenience, our homemade low-carb crust is not only incredibly easy to prepare but also elevates the pie to another level of flavor and health-consciousness. It requires absolutely no baking, making the entire dessert a true no-bake marvel. This crust perfectly mimics the nutty, slightly spiced flavor of traditional graham crackers, providing an ideal base for our tangy key lime filling.

Here’s how to create this simple yet essential component:

1. **Toast the Almond Flour:** This step is absolutely crucial and should not be skipped. Begin with blanched almond flour. Place it in a dry, non-stick pan (or a well-seasoned cast-iron skillet) over medium-high heat. Stir continuously for 3-4 minutes until the almond flour turns a golden color and releases a wonderfully fragrant, toasted aroma. This toasting process is what unlocks the “graham cracker” like flavor profile, adding depth and complexity to the crust. Without it, the crust will taste simply of almond flour.
2. **Combine Dry Ingredients:** Once toasted, transfer the almond flour to a 9.5-inch pie plate. Add your chosen zero-calorie sweetener, a hint of cinnamon, and a pinch of salt. Stir these dry ingredients together thoroughly to ensure even distribution of flavor.
3. **Incorporate Butter:** Gradually add the melted unsalted butter to the dry mixture. Mix everything together until the ingredients are well combined and the mixture resembles coarse, moist crumbs.
4. **Press the Crust:** Using the back of a spoon or your clean hands, firmly press the mixture evenly into the bottom and slightly up the sides of the pie plate. A well-pressed crust will hold its shape beautifully once chilled.

This homemade crust provides a fantastic texture and flavor foundation for your key lime pie, enhancing the overall low-carb and sugar-free experience. Plus, it’s incredibly satisfying to make from scratch!

The Critical Importance of Chilling for a Perfectly Set Pie

For any no-bake pie, and especially for this Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie, adequate chilling time is not just a suggestion—it’s an absolute necessity. The chilling process is where the magic happens, allowing the gelatin in the filling to fully set and create that wonderfully firm, sliceable custard texture. Without sufficient time in the refrigerator, your pie’s crust and/or filling might lack structural integrity, leading to a runny or wobbly dessert that falls apart when sliced.

Think of chilling as the final cooking step for a no-bake recipe. As the gelatin cools, its molecules link together, forming a stable gel that gives the pie its shape. Rushing this step will result in a disappointing texture. We recommend chilling the pie for a minimum of 2-3 hours, but for the best results, an overnight chill is ideal. This extended period ensures the filling is completely firm and the flavors have ample time to meld and deepen, enhancing the overall taste experience.

Furthermore, the type of dairy you use plays a significant role in the pie’s structure. For a robust and perfectly set filling, we strongly recommend using **full-fat Greek yogurt or sour cream**. In our experience, using low-fat alternatives has often resulted in a less stable, wobbly filling, even with proper chilling. The higher fat content contributes to a richer mouthfeel and a more reliable set, guaranteeing a slice that holds its form beautifully.

How to Store Your Delicious Key Lime Pie

Once your Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie is perfectly chilled and set, proper storage will ensure it remains fresh and delicious for days. Store the pie in the refrigerator, making sure it is tightly covered. You can use plastic wrap, aluminum foil, or place it in an airtight pie carrier. This prevents the pie from absorbing any odors from other foods in the fridge and keeps the crust from becoming soggy. When stored correctly, your pie will stay fresh and enjoyable for up to 4 days.

Freezer Tips for Long-Term Enjoyment

This Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie is also freezer-friendly, making it an excellent option for meal prepping desserts or saving leftovers for later. To freeze the pie, first ensure it is completely chilled and firm. Then, tightly wrap the entire pie (or individual slices) in multiple layers of plastic wrap, followed by a layer of aluminum foil. This double-layer protection helps prevent freezer burn and preserves its fresh taste and texture.

The pie can be stored in the freezer for up to 1-2 months. When you’re ready to enjoy it, simply transfer the frozen pie to the refrigerator and allow it to defrost overnight. For a quicker thaw, you can also let it sit on the counter at room temperature for about an hour, or until it has softened to your desired consistency. Freezing and thawing are simple ways to extend the life of your delicious homemade treat!

Explore More Healthy & Delicious Pie Recipes

If you’re looking for more ways to enjoy wholesome, guilt-free desserts, be sure to check out these other fantastic pie recipes:

• Sugar-Free Apple Pie
• Healthy Peach Cobbler
• Healthy Southern Sweet Potato Pie
• Keto Almond Flour Pie Crust
• Keto Pumpkin Pie
• No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie

Discover More Irresistible Sugar-Free Dessert Recipes

Don’t stop at pie! The world of sugar-free desserts is vast and full of delicious possibilities. Expand your repertoire with these other fantastic low-carb and keto-friendly sweet treats:

• Sugar-Free Vanilla Cupcakes
• Sugar-Free Pound Cake
• Sugar-Free Cookie Dough
• Sugar-Free Cheesecake
• Sugar-Free Healthy Banana Bread
• Sugar-Free Apple Crisp
• Sugar-Free Blueberry Crisp
• Sugar-Free Popsicles

Sugar Free Key Lime Pie

Brandi Crawford

This Sugar Free Key Lime Pie is an easy no-bake recipe that uses no eggs! This low carb dessert is made with a sweet graham cracker crust and zesty lime custard filling.

4.91 from 10 votes

Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

Prep Time: 25 mins

Cook Time: 5 mins

Chill Time: 2 hrs

Total Time: 2 hrs 30 mins

Course: Dessert

Cuisine: American

Servings: 10 slices

Calories: 284 kcal

Want to save this recipe for later?

I’ll email it to you, so you can come back to it later! You will also get our free digital cookbook with 30-Minute One-Pot Recipes and weekly recipes and tips.

Equipment

• Pie Plate
• Pie Server
• Hand Mixer
• Mixing Bowl

Ingredients

Graham Cracker Crust

• 2 cups blanched almond flour
• 1 teaspoon cinnamon
• ½ cup zero calorie sweetener
• ¼ teaspoon salt
• ½ cup unsalted butter (1 stick, melted)

Key Lime Pie Filling

• ½ cup fresh key lime juice (See notes for details on key limes; typically 1 pound of key limes yields this amount.)
• 6 oz cream cheese (Softened)
• 1 cup plain Greek yogurt (Use full-fat for best results; sour cream can also be used.)
• ¾ cup zero calorie sweetener (Adjust to taste; see notes for guidance.)
• 1 ½ teaspoons unflavored gelatin (See notes for best practices.)
• ½ tablespoon key lime zest (Adjust to taste; see notes for guidance.)

Optional Garnishes

• Whipped cream
• Lime zest
• Lime slices

Instructions

Crust Preparation

1. Place a skillet on medium-high heat. Once hot, add the almond flour.
2. Stir for 2-4 minutes to toast the almond flour until it’s golden brown and fragrant. This step is essential for developing the “graham cracker” flavor.
3. Add the toasted almond flour to a 9.5-inch pie plate, along with the cinnamon, sweetener, and salt. Stir to combine thoroughly.
4. Gradually add the melted butter and mix until the mixture is well combined and crumbly.
5. Press the crust mixture firmly and evenly into the bottom of the pie plate.

Filling Preparation

1. Microwave the key lime juice for 30-45 seconds. The juice should be warm, but not boiling hot. Then, combine the warm juice with the unflavored gelatin. Stir continuously until the gelatin is completely dissolved, which may take a few minutes.
2. In a separate bowl or stand mixer, combine the softened cream cheese, zero-calorie sweetener, key lime zest, and Greek yogurt. Beat with a hand mixer or standing mixer until the mixture is perfectly smooth and creamy.
3. Pour the dissolved lime juice and gelatin mixture into the cream cheese mixture. Mix well to ensure everything is fully incorporated. This is the crucial stage for taste testing – sample the filling and adjust sweetness or tartness as needed by adding more sweetener or lime zest.
4. Carefully pour the finished filling into the prepared pie crust, spreading it evenly.
5. Chill the pie for a minimum of 2-3 hours, or until it is completely set. For an even firmer result, you may freeze it for 1.5 hours, then allow it to sit on the counter for 10 minutes before slicing and serving.

Video Tutorial

*(Please replace YOUR_YOUTUBE_VIDEO_ID_HERE with the actual video ID for the recipe tutorial.)*

Notes

• A 9-10 inch pie plate will typically yield 10 standard slices. Cutting larger slices will affect the nutritional macros. Feel free to use your preferred macro calculator for precise calculations.
• Key limes (also known as Mexican or West Indian limes) are smaller, more aromatic, and have a tarter, more floral juice compared to regular limes. Regular limes can be substituted if key limes are unavailable, but the flavor profile will be slightly different.
• Zesting key limes can be challenging due to their small size. It’s often easier to zest them before slicing and juicing. Keeping one standard lime on hand for extra zest is a useful backup.
• **Flavor Customization:**
  • For a **zesty pie with moderate sweetness**, use 1 tablespoon of key lime zest and ½ cup of sweetener. This results in a bold, vibrant lime flavor.
  • For a **sweeter pie with moderate lime flavor**, start with ¾ cup of sweetener and ½ tablespoon of key lime zest. Taste the filling; if you desire more lime, add another ½ tablespoon of zest (1 tablespoon total).
• Always taste the key lime filling repeatedly and adjust to your preference BEFORE pouring it into the pie plate.
• Use a nonstick pan or cast-iron skillet to toast the almond flour without oil. If using other pans, a minimal amount of oil might be needed to prevent sticking.
• Toasting the almond flour is crucial for achieving that authentic “graham cracker” taste in the crust. Do not skip this step!
• A teaspoon of vanilla extract can be added to the filling if you enjoy a hint of vanilla flavor.
• Coconut oil can be substituted for butter in the crust using the same quantity.
• For the crust, you can use either powdered (confectioner’s) or granular sweetener. Powdered sweetener often provides a smoother texture in no-bake crusts, preventing a gritty mouthfeel sometimes associated with granular sweeteners. However, both work well in this recipe.
• We do not recommend using bottled lime juice. Its concentrated nature, preservatives, and often metallic taste will negatively impact the pie’s fresh flavor.
• If your filling is too runny or the pie doesn’t set, it’s likely that the gelatin was not fully dissolved or incorporated into the lime juice.
• If you are not concerned about calories and carbs, a store-bought graham cracker crust can be used for ultimate convenience. Similarly, regular table sugar can replace the zero-calorie sweetener if dietary restrictions are not a concern.
• The longer the pie chills, the better the structure of the custard filling will be. Insufficient chill time can cause the crust and/or custard to fall apart.

Nutrition

Serving: 1 slice
Calories: 284 kcal
Carbohydrates: 4g
Protein: 8g
Fat: 26g

Nutrition Data Disclaimer

Macros are provided as a courtesy and should not be construed as a guarantee. This information is calculated using an online nutrition calculator. To obtain the most accurate nutritional information for a given recipe, you should calculate it with the actual ingredients used in your recipe, using your preferred nutrition calculator. You are solely responsible for ensuring that any nutritional information provided is accurate, complete, and useful.

Tried this recipe? Let us know how it was!

Mention @Stay_Snatched or tag #StaySnatched!

Subscribe to our Youtube Channel: Check out our videos!